__ | __|__ | __| | | | | __ | | | | |__|__ | __| | | | | __ | | | | | __|__ | | | | |__| | | | | __ | | | | |__|__ | __| | | | | __ | | | | | __|__ | | | | | __| | | | | | | | | __ | | | | | | | | |__|__ | | | | |__| | | | | __ | | | | | __|__ | | | | |__| | | | | __ | | | | |__|__ | | |--Lydia | (1787 - ....) | __ | | | __|__ | | | __| | | | | | | __ | | | | | | |__|__ | | | __| | | | | | | __ | | | | | | | __|__ | | | | | | |__| | | | | | | __ | | | | | | |__|__ | | |__| | | __ | | | __|__ | | | __| | | | | | | __ | | | | | | |__|__ | | |__| | | __ | | | __|__ | | |__| | | __ | | |__|__
I'd like to suggest that:Reasons:
- Jonah Whipple {94966} is the Jonah Whipple (age 63 at death) who was buried Oct. 27, 1844 in the Owasco Rural Cemetery, Owasco, Cayuga, NY (http://www.rootsweb.com/~nycayuga/cem/cem155.htm);
- Jonah Whipple {94966} is the father of Jonah Whipple {109316};
- Lida (Lydia) Whipple (age 79 at death) bur. Apr 22, 1866 in the Owasco Rural Cemetery, Owasco, Cayuga, NY (http://www.rootsweb.com/~nycayuga/cem/cem155.htm) is Jonah's wife and mother of Jonah Whipple {109316}.
- It would be easy for a transcriber/tombstone reader to interpret 1844 as 1847 (or vice versa), and the Oct. 27 date is too coincidental;
- Jonah Whipple {109316} and other members of his family are also buried in the Owasco Rural Cemetery;
- The coincidence of Jonah Whipple {109316} being named Jonah and that he has a daughter Lydia {109321};
- The elder, widowed, Lydia Whipple is living next to Jonah Whipple {109316} on both the 1850 and 1860 censuses (see below);
- Marshall Whipple {94697} and Harvey Whipple {94970} relocated from VT to Cayuga County, NY; brothers often moved "west" together at that time
I could further speculate that Maria Van Gorder is Maria Whipple, Lydia and Jonah's daughter, as widowed women often lived with their daughter, but that's probably going too far.
- Aug. 16, 1850 Census, Niles, Cayuga, NY, p.146
- head - Van Gorder, John 46 b. PA
- Van Gorder, Maria 41 b. VT
- Whipple, Lydia 63 b. MA {abt 1787}
- June 14, 1860 Census, Niles, Cayuga, NY, p.922 (10)
- head - Van Gorder, Maria 51 b.MA
- Whipple, Lydia 74 b. MA
RIN 110460. Quick link to this page: https://genweb.whipple.org/110460
View this person at the Whipple One-Name Study